Stadium Fever
If Miami history repeats itself, the $644 million budget for the Marlins’ new little Havana home won´t even be in the ballpark.
STORY TOOLS
In February 2000, when Miami-Dade’s Performing Arts Center was a field of dreams in architect Cesar Pelli’s mind, he told county commissioners it could be built for $186 million. The final tabulation was $446 million. Scholars who study overruns term this kind of low-ball estimating a strategic misrepresentation. In baseball, one form this phenomenon takes is the curveball. In other words, Pelli and the folks who managed the PAC’s construction threw the public a lot of curveballs.
Miami-Dade County Manager George Burgess and his statisticians have calculated that the proposed 37,000-seat, retractable-roof ballpark slated to debut in Little Havana in 2012 will cost approximately $644 million. (That’s $515 million for the stadium, $94 million for parking garages, and about $35 million for infrastructure improvements like new water and sewer lines.) Florida Marlins, L.P., the private corporation that runs the baseball team, has signed on for about $155 million, or 24 percent, of it.
Only the manager’s most delirious fans could believe the project will stay inside that budget. Reasonable people, including him, know it’s just a ballpark figure. A baseline, if you will.
“The County’s exposure to overruns and other unexpected costs—while impossible to eliminate completely—has been dramatically reduced,” Burgess wrote to county commissioners in a March 23 memo that accompanied the stadium plan. They approved it the next day, 9-4. (The Miami City Commission also voted 3-2 in favor.)
Put more bluntly, the stadium project will cost more than $644 million. But how much more? Baseball devotees are always inventing obscure but somehow telling statistics, like SLG (Slugging Percentage), QS (Quality Starts), or CS (Caught Stealing). Here’s a new one that stadium finance enthusiasts may enjoy: GOF (Gross Overrun Factor).
The PAC’s GOF was 2.3978—meaning it cost 2.3978 times more than Pelli’s 2000 estimate. If that level of play were repeated, the stadium’s real cost would be approximately $1.5 billion.
Cost overrun scholars have identified another cause of budget lowballing besides strategic misrepresentation. They call it optimism bias and it involves the human tendency of public works project managers to highball their ability to prevent screw-ups.
Indeed, there are more optimistic GOF performances to emulate. Despite a city council-imposed spending cap of $535 million, the budget for Nationals Park in Washington, D.C., which opened last year, grew from $471 million to $611 million—a GOF of 1.2972. If the Marlins’ stadium project fares that well, it will cost about $835 million—a $191 million overrun.
Those with an even bigger optimism bias will like the St. Louis Cardinals’ Busch Stadium, which was completed in 2006. Its budget surged only $21 million, from $344 million to $365 million. With a GOF like that (1.0610), the tally for Miami’s new ballpark would be $683 million, a mere $39 million worth of pessimism.
Miami-Dade County’s agreement with Florida Marlins, L.P. obligates the corporation to pay for all “non-governmentally caused overruns.” It requires the team to hold a $20 million line of credit specifically for that purpose. Taxpayers guilty of pessimism bias have to wonder who would pay for the next $20 million.
“While I cannot assure that there will never be an overrun, or a contractor will never accuse the County or City of having caused them a delay, we have significantly minimized the risk to a level that I feel is manageable,” Burgess wrote in his March 23 memo.
Of course, concerned citizens were already yelling “Foul!” over the decision by city and county leaders to pump any antipoverty and community development tax dollars into a professional ballpark. When Marlins executives or county administrators deliver the first pitch for stadium overrun money, even citizens who never took an interest in baseball may feel like picking up a bat.
2010-09-02 02:53:32
Tawanna FratercangeloWillian MeiserMarget TasmaKirby HendriksonJunior ShulmanDaron SalzerDeloris GayoHong SiderJefferson HarshaDeon RoedeSonny LambethRaymond BergdorfLandon BenyoCandis BresciaAlecia RockinghamSondra ClymoreClaud MedezJovita CihonHee HartwigsenWeldon ZickPercy Kohl
2010-09-02 19:59:33
i likeugg boots,uggs,ugg australia,ugg classic,ugg boots uk,especlially likeugg classic talltall ugg bootsshort ugg bootsuggs salebuy uggbuy ugg bootsdiscount uggbuy uggsugg boots onlinediscount uggsbuy cheap ugg bootsknitted ugg bootsugg boats australia cheapugg boatsbuy ugg sitebuy discount ugg bootsLadies UGG BootsUGG boots sale ugg boatsUGG Classic Tall 5815 Boots very much.there are several styles:ugg 5879ugg 5803ugg 5819ugg 5833ugg 5854ugg 5825ugg 5815ugg 5359ugg 5325ugg 5225 and they are the2010 Hot Selling Boots vibramis the world leader in high performance rubber soles, targeted to the outdoor, work, recreation, fashion, repair and orthopedic markets.five fingers is the featured product of their. vibram five fingers are very famous all over of the worldfive fingers vibramvibram fivevibram five fingers sale,there are several kinds:vibram five fingers classicvibram five fingers flowvibram five fingers kso,if you want to buy cheap vibram five fingersvibram five fingers surgevibram five fingers kso blackbuy vibram five fingersvibram five fingers discountvibram five fingers sizevibram five fingers reviewsvibram five fingers shoesvibram five fingers shoethe vibram five fingersvibram five fingers ebayvibram five fingers womennew vibram five fingersvibram five finger runningvibram five fingers hikingvibram five fingers Bikilavibram five fingers Performavibram five fingers Performa JaneVibram Five Fingers Sprint you can go to vibram5fs.com I want to buyboots shoes,my friends told me aboutugg boots,they saiduggs are very good,and the real brand isugg australia boots fromugg australia andugg uk.winter boots andfur boots are very popolar in winter,especiallyugg sale,ugg boots saleugg boots uk.and theclassic tall is the classic style.ugg boots cheapsheepskin shoesuggs saleuggs ukboots footwearceltic sheepskinlove from australiasheepskin bootslippers bootsclassic tall chestnutugg australia salesheep skin bootsugg boatsceltic sheepskin companysheepskin footwearugg australia onlineaustralia classic tallwomen's classic cardygenuine uggboots There are several stylesugg 5815ugg 5825ugg 5803ugg 5819ugg 5833ugg 5879ugg 5854ugg 5359ugg 5325ugg 5225 There are many brands ofboots shoes,likeugg bootsuggsugg australia boots,ugg australiaugg uk. They are all winter boots and fur boots.ugg saleugg boots saleugg boots ukclassic tallugg boots cheapsheepskin shoesuggs saleuggs ukboots footwearceltic sheepskinlove from australiasheepskin bootslippers bootsclassic tall chestnutugg discountugg australia saleugg boots discountsheep skin bootsugg boatsceltic sheepskin companysheepskin footwearugg australia onlineaustralia classic tallwomen's classic cardy and thegenuine uggboots have this styles:ugg 5815ugg 5825ugg 5803ugg 5819ugg 5833ugg 5879ugg 5854ugg 5359ugg 5325ugg 5225
2010-09-02 21:11:45
Good news,in here wAAe will troduce nike air max shoes to everyone.nike air max 2009,nike air max 2010,nike air max 90,nike air max 95 these series of air max shoes are popular this year,in the same time,nike air max ltd,nike air max classic BW,nike air max 24-7,nike air max tailwind these nike air max shoes also hot sell.in the my-nikeshoes.com also have womens air max,just like womens air max 2009,womens air max 2010,womens air max tailwind,womens air max 90,womens air max classic BW,wwomens air max 95,wwomens air max ltd.not only these shoes,the website have nike kobe shoes,nike lebron shoes and Kevin Durant Shoes.the nike kobe brybant shoes have kobe v shoes,nike kobe 5.5 shoes,nike kobe IV shoes,Nike Hyperdunk Shoes,nike kobe VI shoes;nike lebron James shoes have nike lebron VII shoes,nike lebron VII low shoes,Nike Lebron VII ps shoes,nike lebron VIII(8) shoes,these are the hot sell in the world.last want want to tell u about nike free shoes and air jordan shoes.Now i recommend u can look air max 2009 and air max 2010!THANK U!
2010-09-02 01:42:09
Although ugg bootswere seen more numerous of a cheap ugg boots than for men, more numerous and more guys are now admitting the fact that they too need their own pair of discount ugg boots. This is not only because they are thinking of the functionality of the the ugg boots sale, but also because they are start to think of these as fashion affirmations. If Classic UGG Boots were broken before just to keep the Ft warm, they are now seedy for style as much as for Solace. women ugg boots， This is because there are not just one or two excogitations of UGG Boots but a great number of them have rose up, which can suit the varying styles that seem to be adopted by fashionable men.Discount UGG Boots，Although lambskin is a primary feature of Cheap UGG Boots like their use as a double-faced crucial for the classic tall and short the UGG Boots Sale, there are various boot purposes now that are made of some kinds of leather that just come with the sufficient parchment lining.
2010-09-02 01:25:09
Great choice for me cheap mbt sandals. I stand on my feet all day on concrete floors and find that my feet and back no longer bother me as they did. I am glad I decided to make the investment.discount mbt sandals，This is a great shoe. I had purchased another pair from another source a few months earliermbt sandals sale, but my dog chewed up one of them. I was so happy to find them on Zappos! They had the exact shoe in my size and sent them right out to me. mbt sandals，They are so comfortable and they give me a workout when I walk.cheap mbt shoes， I highly recommend them.Love my discount mbt shoes. I typically wear a 7.5 but needed the 8 in this style. Very comfortable and fun to walk in.mbt shoes， These dorky shoes are giving me SO MUCH RELIEF from my recalcitrant plantar fasciitus heel pain. mbt shoes sale，Actually, I even think they look passably cute now. discount mbt shoes，I love them, I wish they weren't so darn pricey, I'd buy more. mbt sandals，I own two other pairs of cheap mbt shoes but the Fora is by far the most comfortable and best looking. I usually take a size 7 in mbt but needed a size 6.5 in this style mbt shoes sale. I wore them an entire day no blisters or discomfort. I would order a half size smaller because it is a wider shoe with alot of toe room unlike previous styles.
2010-09-02 01:29:01
These are very comfortableMBT Baridi Shoes! I am on my feet all day as a teacher MBT Ema Sandals. My hips and knees are not hurting at the end of the day and my legs feel as though they have had a good workout. MBT Fora Shoes，I do not like the MBT Fumba Sandals. Even though they told me it was the same MBT Kimondo Shoes in every respect but designed to look better...I do not believe them. MBT Habari Sandals，After walking in the new shoe for a week...it is definitely not the same. MBT Imara Sandals， Going back to my old pair and try to get some MBT Karani Shoes more before the old design is discontinued...which I hope they do not do...why not leave a good thing alone. MBT Panda Sandals，Love these! I am not sure how much they work your legs MBT Unono Sandals, although you do have to 'stay balanced' in them. MBT Salama Sandals，It was quite easy to get used to and becomes second nature after wearing them for a few days. MBT Staka Sandals， What I did notice immediately was how comfortable they are MBT Lami Shoes! I don't want to wear any of my other MBT Tunisha Shoes because when I have these on my feet feel great. MBT Changa Shoes，They are an investment, but if you are on the fence, MBT Sapatu Sandals， I would say go for it! I love these boots. So comfortable. MBT Sport Shoes， I have a nerve thing on the bottom of my foot MBT M.WALK Shoes, which they do not help, but no shoes seem to help. MBT Fanaka GTX Shoes，Run a bit small. I bought this shoe to wear at work. MBT Chapa GTX Shoes， I work in surgery so I am on my feet all day long. These shoes have been incredible for support and all day comfort MBT Kaya Shoes. The price tag is higher than I would normally spend on a pair of work shoes, but these have been worth EVERY PENNY!
2010-09-01 20:45:49
uggs for cheap uggs on sale ugg boots sale uggs boots on sale cheap uggs
Poder360 welcomes and encourages reader comments. Permission to post reader comments is assumed, and we reserve the right to excerpt or edit for clarity any comments that are posted. We won't be able to publish all comments. And we can't vouch for the accuracy of posts from readers. Nicknames will be used to identify your post.
